Faux opened in Tribeca in September, but I waited a polite two months to visit. I was ready to meet the creation of George McNally, Keith McNally’s 23-year-old son in the way you might meet your college friend group’s first baby at the 10-year reunion tailgate. You’re excited but you’re also sort of like, “wait why are you here?”
It did distinctly feel like I was at a restaurant run by a 23 year old, because it sort of felt like I was waiting for a text back for much of the meal, while awaiting our wine and also our waitress. The table bread showed up before the bottle of wine we ordered did, but the bread arrived warm, so we dutifully dug in, not wanting to miss the opportunity. I have to say the bread, even without wine, was stellar. They’ve achieved a perfect crunch of the crust followed by a chewy, soft, bouncy inside, wasting absolutely no space to gradient between the two textures. The butter, as I find often at a McNally restaurant, was fantastic and salted, no surprise. We were glad to see the steak tartare ($26) arrived with more of the exquisite bread. Our wine then arrived sometime after we’d spent a few minutes discussing nothing but the delicious bread, and was a welcome, well-priced, Bordeaux blanc (Sémillon, $82). The somm was informal, and made a joke along the lines of “who was the first person to think of wine openers, haha right?,” opened the bottle and left us to it. Perplexed as we were, at least now we had wine.
The steak tartare arrived with shallot, capers, cornichons, and mustard to be mixed in. Being not such a large restaurant, we were surprised with how tricky it was to track down our waitress to request a little extra mustard. Once the game of cat and house had ceased and the steak tartare was sufficiently mustard-ed, it well received. As evidenced by our opting for white wine, we skipped the steak frites and burger, vowing to save for another time, and ordered the half-chicken ($36) and the halibut ($43). The half chicken cinched the experience for me. Golden, seared, crispy, and sitting in a reasonable jus, cozied up with potatoes and a bed of greens that actually complemented the whole plate, rather than just existing nearby, as greens often do. The halibut came floating in lentils and beurre blanc, and was solid but left room on the plate to be desired (literally, as it was slightly petite).
During all the looking around I did while trying to locate our waitress, I noticed the other guests were dutifully playing out their own classic McNally evenings, enjoying their martinis and burgers Algérienne. The script could be set in any scene, from Pastis to Minetta Tavern to Balthazar, but this one, on this very Wednesday evening in November, was set in Tribeca at Faux. And for all the parallels to Papa one could draw, I saw the beginnings of something that can grow in its own direction. As most of us did when we were 23, Faux has room to grow and likely even flourish. It’s the sort of place that I’d have an ear to the ground on for some time, listening for word of menu changes, or stopping by to check in with a martini. There’s highly likely to be a time this winter where I’m feeling iron deficient, which can only be solved by a drenched steak au poivre, medically speaking. Now happily partnered for five years, Faux reminds me of a time when I wasn’t. When every story wasn’t really over yet, always the possibility of returning for more. Ah, being 23.